Hearth Desk vs others

Hearth Desk

Typical desks charge SortSwift-style rent. Hearth Desk undercuts that with Cloud from $49 USD/mo — or Local perpetual if you want the install on your machines. Same counter stack either way.

What “others” actually cost you

Not a brand hit list — the usual monthly desk and marketplace stack shops get stuck with.

Typical rent desk
$300–$500+/mo

Plus seats. Plus “premium” modules. Plus a migration tax when you leave.

  • Data lives on their cloud
  • Features gated behind tiers
  • Scanning-first — weak merchandising
  • Events as an afterthought
Marketplace-first tools
Take rate forever

Great for selling online. Terrible as your only shop desk.

  • No real POS for the counter
  • Buylist rules they control
  • Cloud lock-in on your listings
  • Zero FNM / door ops
Hearth Desk
$49–$199/mo

Cloud: software + hosting, cancel anytime. Or Local: $1,199–$5,499 once — perpetual key on your PCs.

  • Cloud from $49 USD/mo — undercuts the big desks
  • Local perpetual if you want to own the install
  • Scan Match + live multi-TCG (incl. Riftbound)
  • Loyalty merch + events + storefront

At $300–$500/mo SaaS, Cloud Shop ($124 USD/mo) is a fraction of the rent — and Local Shop ($3,299 once) pays for itself in months, then you keep running forever.

Why shops switch

The reasons owners actually leave the other stack.

Price that doesn’t feel like a mortgage

Cloud from $49 USD/mo (software + hosting, cancel anytime). Or Local perpetual — pay once, keep the desk.

Intake that doesn’t fake it

Scan Match uses OCR plus art fingerprint re-rank — not a barcode theater for demos.

Buylist that protects margin

Floors, rarity floors, want-list boosts, auto-reject trash, self-serve kiosk quotes.

Release week without spreadsheet hell

Preorders, deposits, allocations, printable pull lists when product hits the floor.

Not just a scanner

Scanning-first desks lean on a connected storefront and stop short of merchant tools. Hearth Desk keeps intake sharp and adds loyalty merch, custom point rates, decklist matching, TCG-aware search, and social webhooks.

Events that fill seats

Capacity, door check-in, prize desk, Discord + SMS reminders — not a calendar stub.

Leave without a hostage situation

Migration kit with dry-run CSV import. Your stock comes with you.

Full feature matrix

Hearth Desk vs a typical monthly shop desk vs marketplace-first tools. No brand names needed.

● Included ◐ Partial / add-on ○ Missing or weak
Capability Hearth Desk Typical shop desk Marketplace-first
Ownership — who holds the leash
Cloud monthly that undercuts big desks ● From $49 USD/mo · cancel anytime ○ $300–$500+/mo typical ○ Fees forever
Or buy once, keep running forever ● Local perpetual + optional yearly updates ○ Monthly forever ○ Fees forever
Your data on disk you can back up ● Local SQLite · Cloud hosted for you ◐ Often their cloud only ○ Their cloud
Leave without exporting hell ● Migration kit ○ Hostage CSV ◐
Zero commission on in-store sales ● ● ○ Take rate
Cancel Cloud anytime (access follows billing) ● ◐ Often annual lock-in ○
7-day full trial (everything unlocked) ● ◐ Demo crippled ◐
Works offline at the counter ● Local · Cloud needs net ◐ ○
Intake — stop typing every card
Scan Match: OCR + art re-rank ● ◐ Name search ○
Collector number + set hints from scan ● ○ ○
Camera + upload intake ● ◐ ○
Scryfall / multi-TCG catalog (incl. live Riftbound) ● ◐ ◐
ManaBox + generic CSV import ● ◐ ◐
Competitor desk CSV migration (dry-run) ● ○ Why would they ○
Bins, chaos sort, sealed & toys SKUs ● ◐ ○
Dead-stock actions (not just charts) ● ◐ Reports only ○
Customer collection vault → trade-ins ● ○ ○
Bin sorter rules (29 / 9 bin) ● ○ ○
Buylist & counter — where margin dies or lives
Buylist floors + rarity floors ● ◐ ◐ Their rules
Auto-reject below floor ● ○ ◐
Want-list boost % ● ○ ◐
Self-serve buylist kiosk ● ○ ○
Public buylist quote API ● ○ ◐
Trade slips + store credit ● ◐ ○
POS sell + buy modes ● ● ○
Tills, layaway, table time ● ◐ ○
ESC/POS receipts + cash drawer ● ◐ ○
SKU / bin labels ● ◐ ○
Tax by store + GST/PST exports ● ◐ ○
Loyalty tiers, redeem, streaks ● ◐ ○
Points → store merch (custom rates) ● ○ ○
Consignment payouts ● ◐ ○
Channels — sell everywhere without becoming a marketplace serf
Live web store sync (Shopify + Woo / BC / Ecwid / Magento / Wix / Squarespace) ● ◐ Shopify-ish only ◐
Multi-platform product CSV (Woo, Magento, Big Cartel, …) ● ◐ ◐
TCGPlayer mass CSV export / import ● ◐ ●
LAN multi-machine sync ● ◐ Cloud only ○
Live postage rates & labels ● ◐ ◐
Marketplace order queue → ship ● ◐ ●
Demo / TCG-aware storefront (search + deck builder) ● ◐ Connected storefront only ●
Social post webhooks (FB / IG via Zapier) ◐ Add-on ○ ○
Release week & events — the LGS week that matters
Set preorders + deposits ● ◐ ○
Allocations + release pull lists ● ○ ○
Events + capacity + ICS calendar ● ◐ ○
Door check-in ● ○ ○
Prize desk tied to stock ● ○ ○
Discord event reminders ● Add-on ○ ○
SMS event reminders ● Add-on ○ ○
Ops that scale past one laptop
Desktop + hosted web desk ● ◐ ● Web only
Multi-store / warehouses ● Add-on ◐ ○
Auto pricing rules + markets ● Add-on ◐ ◐
Role-based staff access + PINs ● ● ◐
Owner support / vendor tooling ● ◐ ◐
Product telemetry you can turn off ● ○ ◐ Theirs only

The verdict

If you’re fine paying SortSwift-level rent forever, stay where you are. If you want the same counter stack for less — start on Cloud from $49 USD/mo, or buy Local once and keep it.